The Sonographic Dimensions of the Liver at Normal Subjects Compared to Patients with Malaria
Moawia Gameraddin1, 2, *, Amir Ali1, Mosleh Al-radaddi3, Mohaned Haleeb4, Sultan Alshoabi1
1Faculty of Radiological Sciences and Medical Imaging, Alzaiem Alazhari University, Khartoum Bahri, Sudan
2Department of Diagnostic Radiologic Technology, College of Medical Applied Sciences, Taibah University, Almadinah Almunawwarah, Saudi Arabia
3King Fahad Hospital, Al-Madina Almunawarah, Saudi Arabia
4Madani Military Hospital, Madani City, Gezira State, Sudan
To cite this article:
Moawia Gameraddin, Amir Ali, Mosleh Al-radaddi, Mohaned Haleeb, Sultan Alshoabi. The Sonographic Dimensions of the Liver at Normal Subjects Compared to Patients with Malaria. International Journal of Medical Imaging. Vol. 3, No. 6, 2015, pp. 130-136. doi: 10.11648/j.ijmi.20150306.14
Abstract: Determination of the liver size with ultrasound is an important process in patients with Malaria compared with the normal subjects. The purpose of this study was to determine the measurements of liver size by ultrasonography in patients with malaria compared with healthy Sudanese subjects in order to detect extend of liver enlargement. That is many tropical diseases which affect the liver size. The study population composed of 145 cases that had been selected to satisfy the study. They were 105 normal subjects (65 males 40 females) and 40 patients with Malaria from Capital Khartoum were undergone ultrasound examination of the liver. The normal subjects were divided into 5 groups according to their ages (5-102 years). The anteroposterior and craniocaudal dimensions in addition to liver span of the liver with its right and left lobes were measured using the routine ultrasonography and the mean values were recorded. Data was analyzed using statistical software program. There was highly significant difference of mean liver span of normal subjects and patients with Malaria (12.86 vs. 14.272, p-value= 0.000). The mean craniocaudal diameters of the right and left liver lobes were 11.932 ± 2.02 cm and 9.042 ± 2.09 cm for normal subjects and Malaria patients respectively. Highly significant difference existed between anterioposterior diameters of right lobes between the normal subjects and patients with Malaria (12.495 vs. 13.303, p-value= 0.000) There was no significant difference in anteroposterior and craniocaudal dimensions of the left lobe between the normal subjects and patients with Malaria (5.025cm vs. 5.020cm, p-value= 0.938 and 9.079cm vs. 9.042cm, p-value= 0.903). Height was found to have significant correlation for the liver span followed by weight in the normal subjects. Malaria might not have impact on the size of the left lobe. The study concluded that ultrasound is an effective imaging tool and provides valuable data of volumetric analysis of the liver and its lobes in normal subjects and patients with Malaria which is of importance in the daily practice in radiology clinics since it was helpful in diagnosis of hepatomegaly.
Keywords: Ultrasonographic, Dimensions, Liver, Sudanese, Subjects
The liver is the largest organ in the human body lies at the right hypochondriac region and it is divided in to a large right and small left lobes. The right and left morphological lobes of the liver can be further divided into number of small segments for each lobe. It performs a vital function related to metabolism, digestion, immunity and storage of nutrients. The liver is especially important for maintaining a normal blood glucose concentration. These functions made the body tissues alive. The liver size is influenced with many diseases and with the advent of liver transplantation; it has become clear that there is a great need for an exact determination of liver size. Calculated volume measurements made at ultrasound or at computed tomography provide the best estimates [1,2,3].
Ultrasonography of the liver is one of the most common routine investigations which assess the size, texture and pathological changes. It is the first line of investigation for differential diagnosis of suspected liver pathologies. The measurement of the liver with ultrasound is important and useful to assess the size. The liver was routinely measured in the midclavicular line from the dome of the diaphragm and normally has a craniocaudal length of up to 16 cm. A length over 16 cm usually indicates significant hepatomegaly though the bulk of the patient and configuration of the liver should be considered. If the liver measures 16 cm or more it is abnormal in 75 percent of patients. Longitudinal measurement alone is 87 percent accurate in measuring hepatic size. As the liver enlarges, it usually loses its sharp angular configuration becoming lobular in contour with a rounded inferior edge. If the liver length is 13 cm or less, it is considered to be normal in size in 93 percent of cases. Niederau et al studied the normal measurement of the liver with ultrasound; he reported that there was weak correlation between liver dimensions (longitudinal and transverse measurement) and physical data of the study population. He mentioned that longitudinal diameter of the liver alone will give too high or too low a value, respectively [4,5,6].
Scanning of the viscera are carried out to know the normal dimensions and the echo patterns and deviations from normal have led to diagnosis or prediction of pathological conditions . Liver size varies widely according to age. Many diseases can affect its size, ranging from infective processes to malignant disorders. Palpation and percussion are the standard bedside techniques to document liver size, but are far from accurate to detect small increase in size [8,9]. However, available data are limited for the liver, which causes difficulty in defining hepatomegaly sonographically.
Determination of the normal liver dimensions plays a great role in diagnosis of hepatomegaly as there are various diseases in Sudan may cause enlarged liver. In Sudan, Malaria is regarded as one of the most common tropical disease and most of the infected people presented with hepatomegaly. . It is a major health problem and Plasmodium falciparum causes approximately 600,000 deaths each year and the vast majority of the burden of malaria mortality is in sub-Saharan African countries . Diagnosis of malaria remains a major problem in endemic regions especially in the absence of a gold standard s [11,12]. Several studies have examined the role of ultrasound in determining hepatomegaly which is a common complication of Malaria. In our study we have compared the normal sonographic measurement of the liver in normal subjects with the patients infected with Malaria. Sowunmi studied hepatomegaly in acute Malaria and reported that hepatomegaly was more common than splenomegaly and there was positive correlation between liver enlargement and malaria .
There are few anthropometric studies on the normal measurements of liver by ultrasonography in Sudan and therefore, it was thought pertinent to undertake the present study, to assess the normal measurements of liver in the Sudanese population in comparison with patients infected with Malaria. In literature, most of the studies use the liver spam to assess the liver size without ignorance the other measurements of liver lobes. In this study, we aim to provide new parameters of measurement of liver; anteroposterior and craniocuadal diameters of the right lobe are similar to liver span to evaluate normal and abnormal subjects.
The sonographic measurement of the liver is very accurate and there were several studies tested the reliability of ultrasound in assessing hepatic diseases such as hepatocellular carcinoma, hepatic fibrosis, hepatic metastases and dysplastic nodules which might affect the size of the liver. Elstein et al  have studied the accuracy of ultrasound in assessing spleen and liver size in patients with Gaucher disease compared to computed tomographic measurements; he concluded that the two measurement showed a high degree of correlation within a broad range for both spleen and liver volumes. This result confirmed that reproducibility of ultrasound is seemed to be similar to computerized tomography. Another important study concerning reproducibility of sonographic assessment of liver fetal length in diabetic pregnancies reported that the intraobserver SD was 3.06 (95% CI, 2.68-3.59) mm; the interobserver SD was 2.17 (95% CI, 0.59-4.83) mm; the intraobserver correlation was 0.77 (95% CI, 0.63-0.87), and the interobserver correlation was 0.84 (95% CI, 0.51-0.99) .
2. Materials and Methods
2.1. Study Design and Population: This Is a Descriptive Cross-Sectional Study Which Was Conducted in Khartoum State
There were 145 cases had been categorized into two groups; 105 normal healthy subjects, and 40 cases infected with falciparum parasite of Malaria and all diseases that cause hepatomegaly had been excluded. The variables of study were the sonographic measurement of the liver with its right and left lobes. The demographic data such as age, gender, weight, height and residence had been collected using designed questionnaire.
The sonographic measurements of the liver were collected from real ultrasound images. The demographic data were collected with a designed clinical sheet. The exclusion criteria included history of hepatic or biliary diseases, alcohol consumption, diabetes mellitus, upper abdominal surgery, hepatitis B& C, congestive heart failure, fatty or focal hepatic abnormality and all subjects with abnormal liver patterns. Patients with Malaria had been confirmed that there were no history of biliary or hepatic diseases or diabetes mellitus and all diseases that cause hepatomegaly.
2.2. The Ultrasonographic Procedure
The ultrasound real images had been taken with 3.5-5 MHz using Shimadzu machine and General Electric- Logio machine. The examination was performed by three expert Sonologists. The liver with the right and left lobes had been scanned and shown in sagittal and transverse planes and then measurements were performed to get the anteroposterior (AP) diameter and craniocuadal (CC) diameter in addition to the liver span.
Longitudinal views had been performed including sections through mid-line when the probe is placed directly inferior to the xiphoid process and showed the lateral left lobe, aorta and inferior vena cava (IVC). The craniocaudal length of the left lobe is measured from the medial end to the falciform ligament; the AP diameter was measured from the upper margin to the lower edge (wide distance). Liver span is the widest distance measured at full inspiration, it represent the longest diameter. It was imaged and measured from the medial angle of left lobe to the lowermost inferolateral point of the right lobe as shown in figure 1. In literature, liver span describes the distance between the lower border of the liver in the mid-clavicular line obtained by palpation, and the upper border of the liver in the mid-clavicular line detected by percussion .
The transverse scanning was performed with the probe placed transversely in the subxiphoid area and then the probe was swept to the subcostal region with cephalic and caudal angulation. The right lobe is scanned with visualization of the portal vein including the bifurcation and gall-bladder. The widest AP diameter of the right hepatic lobe is measured as shown in figure 2. The scanning was performed with full inspiration.
2.3. Statistical Analysis
The Data had been analyzed by software programmer (Statistic Package for Social Science (SPSS 16.0) using variable statistical tests. The statistical evaluation of data was mainly descriptive. The quantitative variables such as age, AP diameters of right and left lobes, craniocuadal diameters and liver spam, we used mean ± SD, maximum and minimum. For comparison between quantitative variables and to find relationship, Pearson correlation and Independent t-test were applied respectively. Statistical significance was assigned at p < 0.05.
Sonographic measurements of the liver of the normal subjects and patients with Malaria had been performed. Table 1 to table 4 showed the data of the normal subjects while table 5, table 6 and table7 presented the data of the patients with Malaria. Table 1 showed the general measurements of liver lobes among the study population of the normal subjects. The craniocaudal lengths of the right and left lobes were 11.932cm, 9.079cm, while the AP diameters were 12.495cm and 5.025cm respectively. The mean liver span was 12.86cm for the normal subjects. The AP diameters measured from the age groups of 5-10, 10-20, 20-40, 40-60 and 60-102cm; the measurements were 11.05, 12.49, 12.95, 14.03, 11.76cm respectively. These measurements confirmed that AP diameters increase as age advanced until the age of 60 to 102 which revealed unexpected diminished in size (11.76cm) due to age effect. The craniocaudal lengths followed the same way as the AP diameters, decreased with age as shown in table 2.
There was no significant difference of AP diameters (table 3) of right and left lobes between male and female subjects (p-values = 0.389 and 0.805) respectively.
Table 4 showed the comparison of the liver span measurement with the height and weight of the study population of the normal subjects. It was observed that the height could change the liver span measurement (p-value=0.000) and there was also positive correlation (r=0.563), while the weight showed weak correlation(r= 0.439) but there was significant difference (p-value = 0.000).
In patients with Malaria, the mean AP diameter of right and left lobes of the liver were 13.303cm and 5.020cm while the craniocaudal lengths were 12.405 and 9.042cm respectively. The measurement of liver spam was categorized in groups as shown in table 6. Most of liver span measurement was more than 15.5cm which is regarded to be enlarged.
The AP diameters of right lobe of the liver at Malaria patients was significantly higher than AP diameter of the normal subjects (13.303 vs. 12.495cm, p-value=0.000), while the craniocaudal lengths of malaria patients is also significantly higher than those of the normal subjects (12.405 vs.11.932cm, p-value= 0.014).
The AP diameters of the left lobe in patients with Malaria was 5.020cm while in normal subjects was 5.020cm which were not significantly different (p-value= 0.938), while the craniocaudal lengths were 9.079 and 9.042cm of the abnormal and normal subjects respectively (p-value = 0.903) as shown in table7.
Figure1 sonogram shows measurement of liver span, image taken with Toshiba ultrasound equipment at Medani Hospital. Figure2 sonogram shows enlarged right lobe of patient with malaria, image taken with Sonyance4 ultrasound equipment at Medani Hospital.
|variables||Age (years)||CC diameter of the Rt. lobe||CC diameter of the Lt. lobe||AP diameter of the Rt. lobe||AP diameter of the Lt. lobe||Height (cm)||Weight (Kg)|
SD: Standard deviation
|Age groups (years)||frequency||Mean diameter of right lobe||Mean AP Diameter of left lobe||Mean CC Diameter of right lobe||Mean CC Diameter of left lobe||Mean liver spam|
SD: Standard deviation
|AP right lobe||female||40||12.200||3.003|
|AP of left lobe||male||65||5.052||1.524||0.805|
SD: Standard deviation
|Pair 1||Liver spam||13.476||105||1.969|
|Causes of hydronephrosis||Minimum||Maximum||Mean||standard deviation|
|AP diameter of the right lobe||10.0||16.4||13.303||1.2636|
|AP diameter of the left lobe||2.7||10.0||5.020||1.5154|
|Craniocaudal length of the right lobe||10.0||14.9||12.405||1.1618|
|Craniocaudal length of the left lobe||5.7||12.7||9.042||1.8782|
|Total number of patients||40|
|Measurements of liver span||Number of cases||Percentage %|
|Measurements||The mean values at Normal subjects||The mean values at Malaria patients||P-value|
|AP diameter of the right lobe||12.495||13.303||0.000|
|AP diameter of the left lobe||5.025||5.020||0.938|
|CC of the right lobe||11.932||12.405||0.014|
|CC of the left lobe||9.079||9.042||0.903|
Ultrasonography is one of the most common imaging methods which are used in routine practice .There have been quite a few previous reports giving the standard size of liver by ultrasound, but none has been done in the Sudanese population. In contrast to previous studies which were mainly done on the foreign population, our data was obtained from a large age group (5 - 102 years) of healthy subjects of the Sudanese population. These had been compared with the measurements of patients with Malaria to detect hepatomegaly. Liver size may give information about the diagnosis and the course of gastrointestinal diseases. Thus, the determination of normal liver size can be significant. The literature includes few methods for sonographic determination of liver size. The application of different measurement methods has resulted in various estimates of normal liver size . Longitudinal (carniocaudal) hepatic diameter is the most commonly applied and predominant clinical method of estimating liver size in routine diagnostic situations [19,20]. So, approximately no study utilized the measurements of the right and left lobes of the liver as indicators of enlargement.
As well, it proved to be the best measured diameter in differentiating between healthy and diseased livers. Therefore, we chose to use liver span, craniocaudal and anterior posterior diameters for liver size measurement in this study. Our results provide a standard set of normal range of liver size in the normal subjects and patients with Malaria as determined by ultrasonography. In this study, we examined the efficiency sonographic measurement of the liver in normal subjects and patients with Malaria.
In our study the mean or average liver size in the normal subjects was 12.86 cm compared to 10.5 cm and 12.3 cm in Niederau et al.’s and Tarawneh et al.’s studies respectively, our value is higher. This difference may be attributed relatively to the large age group in our study. Patzak et al reported higher value (15.0 ± 1.5) compared to our value . This indicates that liver spam above 15.1cm is regarded enlarged. Consequently, in our study there were 13 patients out of 40 cases of malaria their liver span above 15.1 cm and considered enlarged.
Kratzer et al. conducted a similar prospective study on a larger population to establish normal value for liver diameter at mid-clavicular line and to determine the influence of sex, height, BMI and alcohol consumption on liver size. In their sample, the average measured liver diameter at mid-clavicular line was 14.0 cm compared to 12.86cm in our study . In comparison of our study, we found the average liver size at patients with malaria was 14.272cm which is slightly higher than normal.
In the present study, we found that there was no statistical significant difference between males and females at measurement of AP diameters of the right and left lobes of the liver. In a previous study done by Mittal and Chowdhary , the average diameter of right lobe of the liver of males was found to be 12.99 ± 0.76 cm and it was 12.66 ±1.07cm for females. The average diameter in males was significantly higher than in females. In adults, the diameter was 11.84 ± 1.03 cm, while in elderly subjects the diameter was 13.06 ±0.65 cm. The diameter obtained by Mittal and Chowdhary in their studies was comparatively slightly lower in adult and higher in elder than that obtained by our study. Our data for the right lobe of liver was even similar to the study done by Niederau et al.
In the present study of normal subjects, we found that the average craniocaudal diameter of the left lobe of the liver was 9.079cm. This finding was approximately consistent to the study done by Niederau et al which was 8.3±1.7 cm, but the it was nearly similar to the study done by Mittal and Chowdhary . They reported the diameter of the left lobe to be 9.75±0.61 cm, which is not higher in comparison to that obtained by our study. In patients with Malaria, the AP and craniocaudal diameters of left lobe was not significantly different from normal subjects (9.079 vs. 9.942cm, p-value= 0.903). This result reflects that the size of the left lobe is not influenced with Malaria thus did not enlarge.
In this study we compare anteroposterior diameters for right and left lobes(of normal subjects) between the male and female, we found no significant differences in liver measurements (p-values were 0.389 and 0.805 respectively) in agreement with Da Silva et al.’s study . This is not true in the literature. In a study of 915 healthy adults, Niederau and colleagues found a significant difference between genders, but they did not specify the measurement values . In a study of 116 adults, Castell concluded that gender is a determining factor for liver size . They discovered that men have larger liver size than women and they even proposed a formula for correcting liver measurement by clinical percussion for each gender. In a sample of 2,080 adults, Kratzer and colleagues found a significant difference for ultrasound liver measurement between male and female individuals . Mean value for men was 14.5 ± 1.6 cm and 13.5 ± 1.7 cm for women. In a study of 307 children aged between 5 days and 16 years, Konus and colleagues, however, found no significant size difference in hepatic lobes . In comparison of patients with malaria, we found the AP and craniocaudal diameters of the right lobe revealed high significant difference (12.495 vs. 13.303cm, p-value=0.000 and 11.932 vs.12.40cm, p-value= 0.014). This results indicates that right lobe of the liver is more sensitive to enlargement than the left lobe; AP and craniocuadal measurements could be regarded as accurate indicators to assess liver size.
The study revealed that the liver span of the patients with Malaria normal subjects is significantly higher than that of the normal subjects (12.86 vs. 14.272cm, p-value= 0.000). This is attributed to the infection of plasmodium falciparum which causes hepatomegaly. A study conducted by Zha et al had studied ultrasound diagnosis of malaria; examination of liver, spleen and optic nerve sheath diameter. He confirmed that hepatomegaly >15.1cm is useful since it procures as a specificity of 75%. He reported hepatomegaly (>15.1cm) in 16 cases out of 40 patients with malaria and the average size was 14.76cm . This result is similar to our finding which showed that the average size of the liver of the infected patients was 14.272cm. In our study we find 25% of malaria cases the liver span measurement was above 15.5cm which indicated hepatomegaly. This finding is also consistent with study conducted by Eun Mi et al studied the findings of Malaria infection with plasmodium vivax and he reported that the mean spleen and liver length were significantly higher in the Malaria group .
Children of the normal subject group were included in the present study, in age group 5-10 years, the measurement of craniocaudal diameters of the right and left lobes were consistent with a study conducted in Indian children by Dhingra et al in which liver length was 11.9±1.08 cm and 11.7±1.11cm for the male and female respectively in the age group 8-10 years . In this study, values were higher than that reported by Balcha and Admassi who conducted their study in below thirteen years old Ethiopian children .
In normal subjects, the present study also identified age as a factor influencing liver size. Thus, the published data regarding a correlation between liver size and age remain contradictory [19,22]. Zeeh and Platt showed that both liver weight and liver volume decrease with advancing age . Chouke`r et al. found a reduction in liver weight beginning after age 50 years. Studies by Urata et al. and Vauthey et al., which were conducted with the purpose of establishing a formula for determining liver volume, reported only a slight correlation between patient age and liver volumes [32,33]. Corresponding to this data, we found the liver increases in size between40 and 60 years and decreases after age 60 years. In children there was a reduction in size after age ten years.
In the present study we correlated liver spam of normal subjects to height and weight; we found that there was significantly high correlation with the liver size and height (p ˂ 0.05) in the line of Konus et al study. Konus and his colleagues found that height was showed the best correlation with liver dimensions. They found that body surface area was showed a high correlation with liver, spleen and kidney dimensions, button a lesser degree. Niedarau et al and Udoaka found that there was a weak correlation between liver size and age, height, weight and BMI .
Ultrasound is very effective imaging tool to assess liver size in patients with malaria and normal subjects. The study has provided anthropometric parameters of the liver which will be useful in assessing this vital organ for any pathological enlargement or reduction in clinical practice. The sonographic measurement is very effective imaging modality for evaluating liver size at normal subjects and patients with Malaria. It is recommended to be used to screen the patients with malaria.
Moawia B. conceived the concept. Amir wrote the first draft; Mohanad and Sultan performed the sonographic investigations. All authors involved in the data collection, critically reviewed the manuscript and all approved content of the final manuscript.